What Viewers Really Think about TV Antique Shows: An Intelligent Perspective

So there we have it. The previous articles provided a brief snapshot of The Antiques Roadshow, US style, through the lens of the viewing public. One may not consider them the most discerning bunch but they speak from the heart and they represent a reasonable cross section of this audience. Nevertheless, there are a few sharp and pithy observations camouflaged within this site that deserve more than just an acknowledgement in passing.

I have not watched a moment of this show since that woman came on with her hideous folk art jug that she got at a garage sale for $25 and it was worth over $50,000! The only bigger idiot than someone who would pay $25 for that ugly piece of yuck is someone who would actually shell out FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS for it! This show makes me realise just how money orientated our country has become. When some wealthy collector out there will pay $50,000 for a jug or $800,000 for a side table I just have to think of the things that money could have done for a sick or needy person. The Antiques Roadshow, though interesting at first, merely reinforces our societys obsession with stuff.

The Antiques Roadshow is a wonderful insight into the differences between two cultures. The antiques business in the UK is fuddy duddy, full of eccentric characters and gullible but polite people who just nod pleasantly, saying yes a lot when told their piece is a load of junk etc. The US show is dominated by really annoying presenters, most of whom are flagrantly homosexual, and just plain dull. Also, in the US show there is much more emphasis on price than in the British version where the history of the piece is more important.

A cross between a museum and The Price is Right.

Take equal parts Game Show, Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, Falcon Crest stir vigorously, pour over ice (into a rare 18th century pewter mug) and, voila, you have The Antiques Roadshow.

There is a sense that the US market is much more financially orientated so far as art, antiques and collectables are concerned. The major driver in the various message boards is for an affirmation of the monetary value of an item. This doesnt mean that its intrinsic value, nor its history, are irrelevant but the attention span of the typical consumer in the US is very short. Although there are many educated and informed viewers on US television, it is almost impossible to contemplate a programme with the intellectual rigour of Going for a Song appearing on a mainstream channel. Interestingly, there has been an attempt to resurrect the aforementioned show with the formidable Anne Robinson in the chair though this just seems a ruse to replicate a successful formula without establishing whether there is any latent demand. These television executives really do have to work a bit harder. I reckon you and I could do a better job half the time.

Part four in a series of articles by Howard Lewis.(Read the first three parts in the www.invaluable.com blog).

256mbddrram
Spider Man3movie
Compatiblememory
1gbram
Thegrudge2movie
512mbsdmemorycard
Edgememoryram
Lovelybeauties
Winbookmemoryupgrade
Reno911miami2movie
Knockedupmovie
16gbram
Hostelpartiimovie
Pc2700ddrmemory
Usbflashmemorypendrives
Microxdcard
Turistamovie
Pc133rammemory
Rcamemory
Curseofthegoldenflowermovie
1gbddr2
Usbmemorycardreaders
Systemmaxram
Captivitymovie
Abitmemory
Memoryddrram
Yearofthedogmovie
Jvcmemory
Memoryformacbookpro
Lonelyheartsmovie
Qdimemory
Shootermovie
4gbram
Laptopddrmemory
Macbookprokits
Philipsmemorycard
Themessengersmovie
Seraphimfallsmovie
Extradad
Pathfindermovie
1gbddrmemorypc2700sodimm
G5memory
Sanyomemorycard
Pc2100dddr1gb
Jindabynemovie
256mbsdmemory
Danelecmemorycard
Ddr2533sodimm
Compactflashmemory
Eaglevssharkmovie
1gbpc2100sodimm
Thenumber23movie
1gbpc2700ddr
Nandflashmemory
Thehillshaveeyes2movie
Thebourneultimatummovie
Alienwarememoryupgrade
Crucialram
Deadsilencemovie
512mbrdrammemorypc800
Molieremovie
Theprisonerorhowiplannedtokilltonyblairmovie
Rolandmemory
Inthepitmovie
512mbpc2100
Adaptecmemory
Macmemoryg5
512mbddrram
Audiovoxmemorycard
Intergraphmemory
Oncemovie
256mb133mhz
Disturbiamovie
256mbpc2700sodimm
Simpletechddrmemory
Edgememorycard
Rockthebellsmovie
Psionmemory
Ddr2ram
Thetrippermovie
Daynightdaynightmovie
Waitressmovie
256mbmemorycard
Macraid
256mbpc133sdrammemory
Ddr333memorymemory
Airmemory
Lucentmemorycard
Iomegamemory
Thenannydiariesmovie
Dreamgirlsmovie
Securedigitalmemorycardreader
Notebookmemory1gb
Macstorage
Sdrampcmemory
512mbpc2100ddrsodimm
G4battery
Smokinaces
Memorycard1gb
Residentevilextinctionmovie
Cheaprammemory
512mbpc2100ddr
Pc2100laptopmemory
Pnymemory
Edgememoryusb
Primevalmovie
Sonypicturesclassicsmovie
Warnerindependantpicturesmovie
Sdmemorycardusbadapter
Furmovie
Magnoliapicturesmovie
Memorycardreader
Macintoshcomputermemory
Notesonascandalmovie
512mbddr
Civicdutymovie
Etowermemory
Tyanmemory
Averatecmemoryupgrade
Argusmemory
Kingstonddrram
Macportable
Mitsubishimemorycard
Imacram
Thrillermovie
Closetohomemovie
2gbram
Samuelgoldwynroadsideattractionsmovie
Gp6400memory
Jonestownmovie
Theex2movie
Georgiarulemovie
Licensetowedmovie
Romanticomovie
Philipsmemory
Firehousedogmovie
Nomadmovie
512mbpc2700
512mbpc2700ddr
Okidatamemory
Slowburnmovie
1gbusbflashmemory
Memorymodules
Usbmemorykey
Meettherobinsonsmovie
1gbpc2100ddrsodimm
Flashmemorycard
Thehitchermovie
Foxatomicmovie
Memoryupgraderam
Kingston512mbpc2700333mhz
Sonypicturesmovie
Livefreeordiehard2movie
Universalmovie
Noreservationsmovie
Sunshinemovie
Usbflashmemorydrives
Thehostmovie
512mbmemorycard
Graciemovie
Pnypc2700memory
Thedeadgirlmovie
Thelivesofothersmovie
256mbram
Macexternalstorage
Gp6memory
Wildtigersihaveknownmovie
1gbmemory
Paprikamovie
Sanyomemory
Acermemoryram
Diggersmovie
512mbddrsodimm
Pny512mbddrpc2700
Mpcmemoryupgrade
Newlinemovie
Memoryrdram
Pcflashmemory
G4laptopmac
Macg4computer
Pc2100ddr
Wildhogsmovie
Lionsgatemovie
Konicacameramemory
Sigmamemory
Misspottermovie
Paramountvantagemovie
Laptopsmac
Volvermovie
Macg5
512mbram
512mbddr2
Ramprices
Macbookkits
Thetigerandthesnowmovie
Privatefearsinpublicplacesmovie
Macminiintel
Sodimm512mb
1gbddr2memory
Pc3200memory